
Jessie Birks
The pieces are all coming together. Here in New York, I now have an apartment, a neighborhood, neighbors, a grocery store, a bodega, a mailman (who, when I’m home, I buzz into the building), and now, a job in my field.
So after having moved here two months ago, I now have somewhere to commute to by bicycle. Hurrah! But guess what… given New York’s wealth of transit options, the bicycle was not my first choice.
On Monday, I chose the subway. Union Square is .85 miles from my apartment: kind of a hike. But it’s the perfect place to board a 4 or 5 train (carefully avoiding the 6, because it makes local stops and I am traveling between two express stations) using my trusty MetroCard.
MetroCards can be purchased at almost any subway station using a credit card. They’re also available at certain bodegas, but I don’t know which ones.
After a short wait and a quick (and very cramped) train ride, I have traveled one mile to Grand Central Station, and walk another .18 miles (back in the direction of my apartment) to get to the office. At the time, I hadn’t done the math, but as it turns out, it’s only 2 miles to the office from my apartment, so if I’d been walking the whole thing, it would only have been twice as far.
Subway score:
Distance walked: 1 mile
Time elapsed: 35-40 minutes
One way cost: $2
On Tuesday, I got smart. I rode the bus. I had figured out that since I lived near 1st Avenue, and the train ran up 4th Avenue, and my office was between 2nd and 3rd Avenues (and because Avenues are about .15 miles apart), that it made a lot of sense to take something more direct. Namely, the M15, a bus running north on 1st Ave and south on 2nd Ave.
Riding the bus requires more planning than the subway. Above, I mentioned the MetroCard. You need it to ride the subway, and you also need it to ride the bus. Here’s where Denver has an upper hand, because—for some reason beyond my limited comprehension—you cannot pay for a bus ride in New York City using paper dollars. Only coins and MetroCards are accepted. You also cannot buy a MetroCard at a bus stop or on the bus.
Since I’d decided the bus was better for my needs than the subway, I put a lot of money ($40, which comes with an $8 bonus) on my MetroCard while in the subway station. This would later prove an expensive mistake. But it did allow me to ride the bus and get a good idea of what kind of time it would take.
From my apartment, it is a .44 mile walk to the nearest Limited M15 bus stop. I want the Limited, because the office is near a Limited stop. A little extra walking saves you a lot of riding time over the local bus. Once I get off the bus, it’s a .41 mile walk to the office.
Bus score:
Distance walked: .85 miles
Time elapsed: 30 minutes
One way cost: $2
On Wednesday, I attempted to ride the bus again. On the walk to the bus stop, I checked my wallet for my trusty (now $43) MetroCard. I had lost it! I ran home and looked for it, because I was running early anyway. Nowhere to be found.
After my extensive search, I was running late. I didn’t have time to get to the subway, didn’t have a MetroCard to ride the bus, didn’t think I had time to ride my bike, and was forced to hail a cab.
I’m pretty comfortable taking a cab, so I knew the two important things. First, have cash. They don’t all take credit cards. Second, be in the right place at the right time. At rush hour, it can be impossible to get a cab in certain neighborhoods and on certain blocks. In my neighborhood, it’s always easy to find a cab. Lucky me.
Cab score:
Distance walked: .15 miles
Time elapsed: 20 minutes
One way cost: $9
On Thursday, I was frustrated at having lost my MetroCard, because it was worth so much money. I was doubly frustrated, because the reason it was worth so much money, is because MTA fails to provide adequate MetroCard sales to bus riders.
My response to the frustration? Bicycling! On Thursday, I hopped on Michele, my trusty commuter bike. 10 minutes later, I was at my office.
I’m not going to lie to you. I ran a few red lights. I passed some stopped cars. I rode in the door zone. I broke laws. I was, by Denver standards, riding like a jerk. In NYC, I was the most conscientious, careful and courteous cyclist on the street.
Riding in New York City is dangerous. People turn without signaling. Taxis angle for the curb at the sight of a raised arm. Trucks back up. Vehicles blow through red lights. Fire engines pull out of firehouses. Pedestrians cross against the light, in the middle of the block. Doors are flung open. The vehicle you’re tailing screeches to a halt. Everywhere, from every angle, things try to kill you.
Still, cycling wins. It has turned out to be faster, cheaper and more exciting than all other forms of transit. To be fair, I have calculated the actual cost per mile of riding my commuter bike (initial investment and maintenance costs considered, divided by estimated 10,000 miles of use to date), which is about a dime a mile.
Bicycle score:
Distance walked: 20 steps
Time elapsed: 10-15 minutes
One way cost: 20 cents
I’m sure bike commuting in New York City will get easier and less stressful as time goes on. I can remember when riding on 18th Street in Denver seemed dangerous. When it snows or rains, I might go back to the bus. If transit shuts down, or my bike has a flat, I could even walk.
This column was researched using the Gmap Pedometer, a Google Maps hack that allows you to measure your walking and biking distance.
Subscribe to the BikeDenver RSS feed